We accept all insurance — no DRP contractsCall (602) 600-7825

Blog · Insurance

What Can You Do If the At-Fault Driver's Insurance Delays Your Repair?

When the at-fault driver's insurance company drags its feet, you are not trapped. You have the legal right to bypass their delays and get your vehicle repaired on your own terms.

Why the At-Fault Insurance Company Is Delaying Your Repair

The at-fault driver's insurance company does not work for you, and they have no contract requiring them to resolve your claim quickly. They often delay repairs by claiming they need to speak with their policyholder, perform a prolonged liability investigation, or verify policy limits before authorizing any payments. While they stall, your vehicle sits damaged, potentially racking up daily storage fees if it is stuck in a municipal impound lot or tow yard in North Phoenix or Deer Valley.

File Through Your Own Collision Coverage to Speed Up the Process

If the other insurer is unresponsive, the fastest way to get your car repaired is to file a claim under your own collision insurance policy. Your insurance company is contractually obligated to handle your claim promptly, meaning they will pay for the repairs, minus your deductible, and then pursue the at-fault driver's insurance carrier to recover the costs later. While policy terms and state laws vary, and this information does not constitute legal advice, utilizing your own coverage is often the cleanest way to bypass third-party stalling tactics.

Move Your Car to an Independent Shop Immediately

Do not let your vehicle sit in a storage lot or an insurance-designated clearing yard while insurers argue over liability. Municipal and private storage fees in the TSMC corridor, Anthem, Cave Creek, and Scottsdale can accumulate to thousands of dollars very quickly, which the insurance company may later refuse to cover. You have the absolute right to choose your repair shop in Arizona, so moving your vehicle to an independent, family-owned shop stops the mounting storage fees and ensures your vehicle is in the hands of professionals who advocate for you, not the insurance company.

If your car is stuck in a Phoenix tow yard or you are dealing with an insurance runaround, call Airpark Auto Collision at (602) 600-7825. We specialize in pulling vehicles out of impound and storage yards fast, and we never participate in insurance direct repair programs—meaning we answer to you, not the insurer.

  • Contact your own insurance agent to discuss initiating a subrogation claim.
  • Instruct the current storage facility that you are releasing the vehicle to your chosen independent shop.
  • Avoid signing any authorization forms from the at-fault insurer's preferred repair shops.
  • Request a detailed, itemized list of any storage fees already incurred to protect your financial interests.

Common Questions

Will my insurance rates go up if I file through my own policy for an accident that was not my fault?

In Arizona, state insurance regulations generally prohibit insurance companies from raising your premiums for accidents where you were not at fault. However, policy details and individual carrier practices can vary, so it is always wise to confirm the specific terms of your policy with your agent. Filing through your own collision coverage is a standard industry practice designed to get your vehicle back on the road when the other carrier is stalling.

Who pays the towing and storage fees while the other insurance company delays the claim?

You are legally obligated to mitigate your damages, which means you cannot let your car sit indefinitely racking up storage fees. If you file through your own policy, your insurer will typically pay these fees up front and recover them from the at-fault party later. Moving the car to an independent shop quickly is the best way to prevent insurance companies from denying unpaid storage bills due to an unreasonable delay.

Call Airpark Before You Make a Decision

If your insurance company is telling you where to take your car, your vehicle is sitting in an impound lot, or your claim is being delayed — call us first. We'll explain your options.